Publications /
Opinion

Back
Will emerging economies face a hard landing?
Authors
January 26, 2022

The year began with simultaneous signs of a slowdown in global economic growth and a reorientation toward tightening of monetary policies in advanced economies. In its latest Global Economic Prospects released on January 11, the World Bank forecasts that, after a global growth surprisingly at 5.5% last year, it should moderate to somewhere around 4.1% and 3.2%. % in, respectively, 2022 and 2023.

In addition to the effects of omicron at the start of the year, less fiscal support and lingering supply chain disruptions and bottlenecks point to such a slowdown. In the United States, business and consumer confidence surveys in December already suggested a landing in progress, as well as the decline in mobility levels at the beginning of the year.

For China, the World Bank forecasts a GDP growth of 5.1% this year, below the 8% estimated for 2021. In addition to possible restrictions on mobility due to the “zero covid” approach, the adjustment in the property sector will contain consumer spending and residential investment.

While advanced economies and China reduce their pace of expansion, central banks are on a tightening path – apart from the Chinese case. The Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) of the Federal Reserve Bank (Fed) of the United States meets on Tuesday and Wednesday of this week. But the reorientation of its monetary policy since October has been clear in the minutes of their meetings since then and in statements by its president Jerome Powell. In addition to unemployment rates below 4%, consumer price inflation ended the year at 7%, a level not seen since the early 1980s. Its approach as a “transient” phenomenon has been abandoned by the Fed.

While the FOMC meeting last September suggested an interest rate hike this year, the stakes are now three or four. In addition, the end of the Fed's bond-buying program was brought forward to March, while Jerome Powell telegraphed that the Fed's balance sheet reduction should begin sooner than expected, perhaps as early as mid-year.

After interest rate hikes in England, Norway, and New Zealand, the same is expected in Canada later this month. Moves in the same direction by the European Central Bank and Sweden are now anticipated for early 2023.

This is the external scenario faced by emerging and developing economies, whose slow recovery from the pandemic is expected to continue. The World Bank does not expect their return to pre-pandemic GDP and investment trends in 2022-23 (Figure 1).

figure 1

High inflation rates and public indebtedness during the pandemic are constraining the adoption of expansive fiscal and monetary policies in these countries. Not coincidentally, higher interest rates and the downward revision of fiscal support have taken place in most cases. The question is whether the growth slowdown with tightening financial conditions in advanced economies is likely to be disastrous for them, with landing becoming a hard one in their case.

Tightening external financial conditions will doubtlessly accentuate emerging market policy makers' challenges. For emerging market economies that are currently undergoing significant domestic inflationary pressures, the risk of additional pass-through pressures from currency depreciations after markets embed higher US interest rates will be key in setting monetary policy. In this case, while monetary policy tightening cycles began in 2021 in Brazil, Mexico and Russia following inflation rates moving above their targets, central banks in India and Indonesia maintained an accommodative stance, given low domestic core inflation rates.

Pro-cyclicality of capital flows would also be a factor impacting those countries. Emerging market economies with a high share of foreign participation in domestic capital markets and more open financial sectors are vulnerable to the volatility of such flows. Central banks in these countries may be forced to tighten monetary policy beyond what would be adequate from a growth perspective. South Africa and Mexico are such potential cases. In cases of financial markets largely domestically funded – as it is currently in India, Brazil, and Malaysia – the vulnerability to capital outflows driving substantial currency depreciation is lower.

However, the answer to the question about the nature of landing of emerging market economies will ultimately depend on how aggressively the monetary policy reorientation in advanced economies takes place. If inflation moderates in the United States, due to reduced fiscal stimulus and fading supply chain restrictions, while growth remains minimally robust, emerging markets could avoid a hard landing. Several factors favor such scenario.

First, there has not been a large inflow of foreign capital into emerging market economies in the recent past. Jonathan Fortun, in the capital flows tracker by the Institute of International Finance (IIF) of January 10, suggests that there has already happened a “sudden stop” in such flows, albeit with great differentiation between emerging markets. One may expect that there are no external resources to flee massively in the event of a gradual rise in external interest rates.

Sergi Lanau and Jonathan Fortun, from the IIF, also highlight that emerging-market current account deficits have been remarkably low or nil in the last two years. Figure 2 illustrates that by displaying trade imbalances. In the case of Latin America, foreign reserves increased in 2021, following the reinforcement of liquidity buffers started in the second half of 2020, in addition to the increase in Special Drawing Rights (SDRs) by the IMF in the middle of last year.

figure 3

What about exchange rates? Are they at levels of overvaluation that make them vulnerable to sudden and catastrophic devaluations? Here Robin Brooks, Jonathan Fortun, and Jack Pingle, from the IIF, suggest a more heterogeneous picture: although most emerging currencies have experienced real devaluation in the last ten years, there is huge differentiation, with some now exhibiting sharp devaluation and others overvaluation.

In the case of Brazil, for example, they estimate a degree of around 20% of excess devaluation of its local currency below what its fundamentals would say, such as current account balances and stocks of foreign assets and liabilities. The non-return of the exchange rate to pre-pandemic levels contributed to the Brazilian inflation ending 2021 in double digits – on top of food and energy shocks. In any case, in the case of Brazil and other emerging countries without exchange overvaluation, a high probability of dramatic exchange rate adjustments is not foreseen... provided that, in turn, the reorientation of monetary policy in advanced countries also does not take on dramatic contours.

Thus, we maintain the scenario suggested last July. Except in the case of drastic monetary adjustments in advanced economies, one must focus on domestic factors to understand the weaker performance of emerging markets in the immediate future ahead depicted in Figure 1.

RELATED CONTENT

  • Authors
    September 24, 2024
      This paper was originally published on t20brasil.org The resurgence of Neo protectionism as a reality is creating a pressing need to establish New Industrial Policies (NIPs) capable of striking a balance between Global Value Chains (GVC) managers' quest for efficiency and policy makers' need for more increasing resilience or national security in a turmoiled geopolitical landscape. Furthermore, although NIPs might pursue legitimate non-economic objectives, they are often captured ...
  • Authors
    Under the supervision of
    July 12, 2024
    The report will soon be available for purchase.   The 2024 Annual Report on the African Economy is dedicated to monetary and financial issues on the Continent. There are three reasons for this choice. African economies are exposed to macro-financial instabilities partly generated by global monetary and financial turbulence. The Continent’s currencies and financial systems are engaged in very different dynamics, where routine methods and daring, if not risky, practices coexist. ...
  • Authors
    January 2, 2024
    This paper was originally published on The South African Institute of International Affairs (SAIIA) In order for Africa to raise living standards, create employment for youth and diversify exports, it must industrialise. Until recently, sub-Saharan African (SSA) countries made limited progress in manufacturing value addition and employment, mirroring the de-industrialisation trend seen in many developing countries. To propel industrialisation, SSA countries should adopt flexible st ...
  • Authors
    November 21, 2023
    Multiple shocks faced by the global economy over the past three years have apparently shaken the conventional wisdom on gains from economic integration, and have sparked widespread calls for protectionist and nationalist policies. Is there already evidence of some ‘deglobalization’, or do the factors that underlie globalization remain strong enough despite the shocks? So far, there are no signs of an overall reversal in the long-term trend of greater global trade integration. Howev ...
  • Authors
    November 2, 2023
    The global economic environment has changed as the U.S.—and to a less confrontational degree, the European Union—have clearly established a context of technological rivalry with China. Hindering China’s progress in the sophistication of semiconductor production has become a centerpiece of current U.S. foreign policy. While the U.S. is clearly winning the semiconductor war, the picture is different when it comes to clean-energy technology. Both technology wars overlap with access to ...
  • Authors
    Sous la direction de
    Omar Awadallah
    Muhammad Ba
    Farah Bashir
    Said El Hachimi
    Mostafa El Sayed Abo El Soud
    Saloi El Yamani
    Pierre Jacquemot
    Divine Ngenyeh Kangami
    Hafsa Maalim
    Samuel Muriithi
    Solomon Muqayi
    Brian Kelly Nyaga
    September 21, 2023
    Cette édition du Rapport économique de l’Afrique est construite autour d’une thématique d’une grande actualité : les conséquences des incertitudes et des risques aussi bien sanitaires que climatiques et sécuritaires sur les économies du continent. L’exercice est d’autant plus légitime que la recomposition de l’ordre mondial questionne la place du continent à l’échelle planétaire, sur les plans économique, social et environnemental. L’économie mondiale est confrontée à des défis glo ...
  • Authors
    Pierre Sauvé
    May 29, 2023
    Morocco has made important strides in reducing poverty in the last three decades, thanks in large part to trade and industrial policies aimed at durably inserting the country into world flows of goods, services, and cross-border investment. Since 1992, per capita incomes have tripled (in current US$), contributing to a threefold drop in the Kingdom’s poverty headcount. The country of 37 million features consistently as one of the better-performing and more stable economies in the No ...
  • Authors
    Inkyo Cheong
    Lillyana Daza Jaller
    Siwook Lee
    Jean-Christophe Maur
    Martin Molinuevo
    Sahar Sajjad Hussain
    Pierre Sauvé
    Shane Sela
    Aleksandar Stojanov
    Iryna Klytchnikova
    Edited by Pierre Sauvé and Uri Dadush
    May 23, 2023
    The broad thrust of Morocco’s trade and industrial policies over the last thirty years has been to anchor Morocco into world flows of goods, services, and cross-border investment. Despite the challenges posed by the COVID-19 pandemic, rising international prices, and a complex geopolitical environment, Moroccans continue to derive significant benefits from their economy’s openness. These include improved consumer choice and welfare, the growing insertion of Moroccan firms into cross ...
  • February 27, 2023
    In this interview recorded during the Atlantic Dialogues, Mr. Helmut Sorge, Columnist at the PCNS interviews Mr. Masood Ahmed, President of the Center for Global Development about his insights on Globalization between yesterday and tomorrow. In fact, although the process of linking coun...