Publications /
Opinion

Back
A Relapse into conflict?
Authors
December 15, 2021

How do you treat a brutal dictator who had lost power after 42 years, hiding in a drainpipe, after his convoy was attacked by fighter jets from the air? It was a bloody mess and not a pretty scene. The dictator had a few seconds to beg for his life, “what did I do to you», he gasped reported the London Guardian on October 22, 2011, and then his turbulent life came to an end, shot with a pistol. Triumphantly his assassin raised Gaddafi’s golden revolver -- a few minutes of global fame, later, the shadow of death touched the rebel as well.

A decade ago, on October 23, 2011, the Financial Times wrote: “Libya declared Liberation after Gaddafi’s death.” The end of the dictator was so improbable that authorities decided to keep his body for a few days in a commercial freezer, so there would not be any doubts for his followers that their hero had left life. Ultimately, the ruler was bathed buried, with one of his killed sons next to him, in a secret desert spot.

Finally, the day had come to begin the transition from tyranny and oppression towards democracy, competing tribes united, the national treasures, oil, and gas shared by the people, and the disempowered inhaling freedom. Instead of unity, two more civil wars in ten years followed; on February 16, 2015, Rebecca  Murray reported in “Al Jazeera: “The situation is just terrible. Mounting chaos has gripped the country.”

Libya “has been awash with weapons since the 2011 uprising that toppled Muammar Gaddafi, and opposing militias have since been battling for control of its cities and oil wealth.”(The Guardian). Russian, Sudanese, Syrian mercenaries were also involved, fighting for their funders. There were two sides: the Libyan government in Tripoli, the Government of National Accord (GNA), recognized by the United Nations and supported by mainly Ankara. In the eastern side, based in Benghazi and Tobruk, the self-appointed Field Marshall Khalifa Haftar,77, a renegade former general (who took part in the coup which brought Gaddafi to power in 1969), heading the “Libyan Arab Armed Forces” (LAAF), which received funds and weapons from an unlikely coalition of Russia, the United Arab Emirates, Egypt, France, Saudi Arabia, and Jordan.

Rewinding the clock, on February 15, 2011, an uprising was staged in the seaport city Benghazi, the second largest of Libya, and a “National Transitional Council” founded. Troops loyal to Gaddafi tried to defeat the resistance. Still, local militias fought back, and French fighter jets (authorized by a UN resolution to protect the civilian population) and rebels forced the Gaddafi soldiers to retreat, and the civil war continued.

In 2011, Haftar returned from a two-decade exile in the US to join the Libyan revolution. He was ultimately chosen as commander of the then-Libyan National Army (LNA) by the House of Representatives in March 2015 in a process fraught with pitfalls. Al Jazeera: “Haftar has become one of the most divisive figures in post-revolutionary Libya. » And, again Rebecca Murray : «Now Libya is bitterly split. It has two opposing governments, parliaments and fighting forces intent on seizing the country’s power and assets”. In April 2019 Haftar released a recording on Facebook declaring war against the UN-backed government.

As a result, a war raged on Tripoli’s outskirts for months, battles in which the Russian Wagner Group intervened with about 3000 mercenaries in Libya, as estimated by the US Department of Defense, trying to lead Haftar to victory. In total, 22 OOO foreign fighters have been estimated to be fighting over the years. Turkey, besides sending Syrian mercenaries, intervened in active combat in January 2020 with armed drones while air defense systems were deployed.

 

Imposing peace by force

A cease fire was reached in September 2020 - the LAAF forces and the Wagner group had retreated to Sirte, a strategic city at the opening of the oil crescent in Libya’s center. On March 21 of this year a government of National Unity (GNU) was formed, the agreed sole legitimate authority in the country.  December 24, 2021, was chosen to be a historic day—free elections in Libya. Finally, A new parliament, a new President.  On November 16, 2021, Haftar declared, that he would be a candidate for the Presidency. « The Elections in Libya: A Troubled Democratic Transition” stated Noamane Cherkaoui in his Policy Brief for the “Policy Center for the New South” (October 2021, PB-36/21).

The author states in his detailed and well-documented analysis, ”the political process is at a standstill… There is no consensus-based electoral law setting out how elections in December will be held, which also papers over disparate concerns of election integrity and post-election state-formation plans.” Cherkaoui, postgraduate in International Relations at the University of Leicester suggests in his brief, that “the democratic transition in Libya may be in peril because of an escalating, multidimensional crisis in the country. The crisis’ internationalized nature has undermined domestic stability, with many countries vying for influence and the spoils of war”. Cherkaoui notes in detail why some of the foreign nations are reluctant to depart from Libya. For example, for Italy, Libyan hydrocarbons fulfil 10% of its energy needs, importing more than 20 % of its crude oil from Libya pre- 2011- with its interests mostly in the west of Libya.

ENI, the Italian energy company announced that it would develop its offshore presence in Libya towards increased gas production. “Russia has been a key player in Libya”, writes the Policy Center expert, “propping up the LAAF militarily and economically. It hopes to gain preferential access to oil reserves as well as another naval base to encircle NATO and to further solve its strategic impediment of a lack of numerous warm-water bases.” France has backed Haftar and the LAAF, which seems hardly a surprise: Total is securing its oil investments since the 1950’s with “France importing more than 15% percent of its crude oil needs from Libya-pre-2011.” Turkey strongly backed the internationally-recognized GNA, signing bilateral deals on maritime boundaries and military cooperation. « This, noted Cherkaoui, has led to close coordination with the Government of National Unity” (GNU), particularly on security issues, and Turkey has an ongoing presence in bases in Tripoli and Misrata.

A man named Gaddafi wanted for war crimes by the “International Criminal Court” (ICC), sentenced to death by firing squad by a court in Tripoli 2014 for crimes against humanity, committed during the revolt, which his father did not survive - Seif al- Islam el Gaddafi, 49, received contributing writer Robert Worth of the New York Times Magazine in a guarded compound near Zintan, Southwest of the capital Tripoli, suggesting he may run for President: «Qaddafi’s son is alive. And he wants to take Libya back;” (New York Times, July 30, 2021). Those unfortunate legal issues, Gaddafi Junior is confident, “could be negotiated away” if a majority of the Libyan people choose him as their leader. For years the second son of the dictator had not been seen; captured in a remote desert town named Awbari by a militia, then kept hidden, presumably one day to exchange the prisoner for cash, or political favors. “I have been away from the Libyan people for 10 years. It would help if you came back slowly, slowly like a striptease. It would help if you played with their minds a little.” The politicians following his father’s rule have brought “nothing but misery. It is time for a return to the past.” A possible, yet unlikely return of a Gaddafi to power, wrote Robert Worth, « would certainly be a symbolic triumph for Arab autocrats who shares his loathing for the Arab spring.” The dream was seemingly short, too short for the nostalgic followers of Gaddafi senior- his comeback kid Saif al-Islam was one of 25 candidates of the official 98, rejected and declared ineligible  by the Libyan election commission. He decided to appeal, but when his lawyer tried to enter the court building in the southern city of Sebha, gunmen stopped him from filing his papers, an act immediately criticized by the UN representative as a violent attempt to interfere in the election process. However, he was finally permitted to run by the Sebha court on 2 December.

Now the dreamer possibly has more time to finally put into place his retrogressive vision for Libya. He has a brother, Saadi, who escaped to Niger while the people of Libya revolted against the Gaddafi regime. Since he was deported in 2014, the former football professional, whose wealth allowed him to be part of the Italian professional team of Perugia, was imprisoned in Tripoli. The “National Reconciliation Program”, launched by the present and interim government, agreed to declare an amnesty for political prisoners, including Saadi Gaddafi and Ahmed Ramadan, the son of the dictator and his personal secretary, who was released the first week of September.  However, there was no similar dream for this Gaddafi-son to revive the past. No vengeance. Barely released from jail, he took a private plane to Istanbul.

 

The opinions expressed in this article belong to the author.

RELATED CONTENT

  • Authors
    April 2, 2020
    On January 24, 2020, the Bana, a freighter, left the Turkish port of Mersin. Its destination was the Tunisian harbor of Gabes. It was a routine trip, until its transponder was deactivated and the ship disappeared from the radar. No mayday was received; the boat vanished like a ghost. Four days later a satellite observed three dots approaching Tripoli, Libya and when the images were enlarged, it became clear that the Bana was on a secret mission, since she was shadowed by two Turkish ...
  • Authors
    January 30, 2020
    Increasingly, the United Arab Emirates (UAE) strengthens its position within the Arab region that is of strong geopolitical attributes. There has never been as much diplomatic and military activism in the UAE’s history as in the last decade. Such a situation raises major questions about the nature and the impact of the new strategic extension of the country. This article aims at discussing the determinants and objectives of the new strategic positioning of the UAE. A special focus w ...
  • Authors
    January 20, 2020
    Le 3 octobre 2016, la Turquie a déposé une plainte contre le Maroc devant l’Organisation Mondiale du Commerce (OMC) au sujet des mesures antidumping appliquées par le Maroc contre les exportations turques en Acier laminé à chaud.1 Suite à l’échec des consultations entre les deux pays, la Turquie a demandé, le 12 janvier 2017, l’établissement d’un groupe spécial pour examiner la conformité des mesures prises par le Maroc avec le droit de l’OMC. Demande qui marque le passage du litige ...
  • January 17, 2020
    The drone strike that claimed the life of Iranian general Qasem Soleimani unmasks the limits of so-called "hybrid" – or "asymmetric" – strategies. These low-intensity military operations, conducted through unofficial paramilitary forces, are supposed to allow a weaker state to gain geopolitical advantages without risking an open war with a stronger one. The idea is to gradually accumulate small tactical victories by capitalizing on more powerful states’ lack of appetite for distant ...
  • Authors
    January 15, 2020
    “The Nightmare we feared has arrived” Death was late because the departure time of the plane was delayed. But death arrived- six minutes after takeoff from Tehran’s “Imam Khomeini International Airport. It was still dark, 6.12 hours’ local time, when flight 752 of “Ukraine International Airlines” took course toward Kyiv, the Ukraine capital three hours and fourty two minutes away. The Boeing 737 800 NG had reached 2400 meters, when the American military’s “Space Based Infrared Syst ...
  • Authors
    January 3, 2020
    La Libye entame l’année 2020 dans une atmosphère d’escalade. Le conflit s’internationalise et menace la stabilité d’au moins trois régions imbriquées par le fait géographique, les intérêts géopolitiques et par la continuité historique: - Toute la région méditerranéenne est concernée par la conjoncture libyenne. Qu’il s’agisse de sa partie orientale (Egypte, Turquie, Liban, Syrie, Israël, Chypre et Grèce) ou de son flanc occidental (Maroc, Algérie, Tunisie, France, Italie et Espagne ...
  • Authors
    Osama El Mourabit
    November 29, 2019
    During the past few years, the different global ongoing events have left us baffled and astonished. Given the decreasing ability to understand and assimilate the amount of changes, mutations, and crises, one would wonder: what happened to the global order? How has -in this short period of time- the power of its values and institutions that much decreased? What are the causes for these protectionist and massive populist waves? Why are we witnessing an increasing settlement of conflic ...
  • Authors
    Joseph Hammond
    September 17, 2019
    The author is an alumnus of theAtlantic Dialogues Emeging Leaders Program 2018. In the strategic waters near the straights of Hormuz in many ways such it’s the 1980s all over again. Recent mine attacks on maritime traffic and the capture of multiple vessels by Iran harks back to the so-called “Tanker War.” A nested conflict within the larger Iran-Iraq War the “Tanker War” involved American warships escorting oil tanker traffic through the Straights of Hormuz despite Iranian interd ...
  • Authors
    July 1, 2019
    One week ago, Bahrain has hosted the "Peace to Prosperity" workshop to discuss what the United States has described as the economic part of President Donald Trump's "deal of the century", his proposal for solving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The Palestinian leadership boycotted the meeting on June 25 and 26 in Manama, leading critics to question the credibility of the event. Below is an international press review of events preceding the workshop by Helmut Sorge, former Foreign ...