Publications /
Opinion

Back
The Global War of Subsidies
Authors
April 15, 2024

Prior to her visit to China on April 4—her second in nine months—Janet Yellen, United States Secretary of the Treasury, sent a message demanding that the country should not flood the world with cheap exports of clean energy. This would distort global markets and harm workers abroad, she said. According to a senior U.S. Treasury official, China’s excess industrial capacity and the government support that has fueled it were subject of discussion during her meeting with Chinese Premier Li Qiang.

Current levels of ample idle capacity and consumer restraint are some of the challenges China must address if it is to achieve higher economic growth. Exports, as in the past, may well be the sought-after means of addressing domestic demand insufficiency. Not surprisingly, everyone closely monitors the evolution of the Chinese exchange rate to see if there is any devaluation underway. As well as Yellen, officials from other major advanced economies occasionally refer to a potential flood of Chinese products.

Xi Jinping, meanwhile, has referred to clean energy and other high-tech sectors as the primary path forward for the country’s prosperity. As we discussed previously, China today is ahead of the United States and Europe in technological rivalry in clean energy. It is no wonder, then, that U.S. and European officials make frequent reference to Chinese exports and subsidies in this area.

The fact is that large-scale subsidies have proliferated in a race to subsidize so-called ‘strategic’ sectors. In response to China’s subsidies, the U.S. Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) and CHIPS and Science Act have put in place attractive subsidies for local production of clean-energy products and semiconductor equipment. Volkswagen called this a gold rush when announcing a decision to build an electric vehicle (EV) factory in South Carolina.

On the basis that it is supporting investments to combat climate change and reduce healthcare costs in the country, the U.S. IRA includes huge subsidies in the form of tax incentives, grants, and loan guarantees to bolster manufacturing in the U.S. While some of the subsidies, particularly those related to EV batteries, are available for investments in countries with which the U.S. has some free-trade agreement, their scope and value are lower than those available to companies committing to manufacture within the country.

Similarly, the CHIPS Act aims to subsidize a revival of the U.S. semiconductor industry. The US leads in the sector in terms of core technology and equipment, but mass production of advanced semiconductors occurs mostly abroad (Taiwan, South Korea, Japan, and - in the case of manufacturing equipment - ththe Netherlands). The law aims to reduce dependence on Taiwan in the event of a crisis in that country. Expenditures with the IRA alone, originally estimated at $385 billion, are expected to reach $1.2 trillion according to analysts.

The European Union (EU) has responded. The EU expressed almost immediate concern about the IRA, with protests focused on provisions that strengthen domestic production in the U.S. European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen called for the establishment of an EU Sovereignty Fund (ESF) to directly combat the effects of the IRA.

She stated that the EU needs to consider “how our so-called 'like-minded partners' are proceeding in the ongoing industrial and technological race”. The EU has had to ease rules that limit national government subsidies to industry. For the first time, national governments of EU member states can match subsidies offered outside the EU, if there is a risk of a project of ‘strategic importance’ being relocated elsewhere.

In addition to defending against the IRA, the EU is obviously concerned about China. Its automotive industry is eyeing the penetration of Chinese EVs, production of which, including in Hungary, has already been announced. Declarations of intent to establish trade restrictions in response to Chinese subsidies have been made.

South Korea and Japan have also implemented their own responses to subsidies from the outside. South Korea, after initially describing incentives for EVs and batteries manufactured in the U.S. as a “betrayal”, received updated guidance on the IRA from the U.S. Treasury that extended some tax incentives to them. Japan also obtained a similar agreement, qualifying its EV batteries and components for IRA incentives.

The major battery and semiconductor companies in both countries are planning new factories in the U.S. to ensure they continue to receive U.S. subsidies, as local content requirements under the IRA become more stringent over time. However, both the South Koreans and Japanese have acknowledged that U.S. subsidies also pose a threat to their own domestic industries. Both pursue a dual strategy covering incentives available under the IRA, while implementing their own national subsidy policies to protect key sectors.

Even Australia, which has a free-trade agreement with the U.S. and little industry to protect, has decided to enact a subsidy program seeking to bolster activity in areas such as batteries and critical mineral processing, which are considered strategically significant.

Judging by announcements and initial investments, the effect of incentives on U.S. supply chains has been intense. Mexico—partnered with the U.S. via the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement, and therefore a beneficiary of the IRA—replaced China as the largest exporter to the U.S. last year, marking the first time since 2006 that China has not been the largest. There is a realignment of global trade underway.

Any economic evaluation of costs and benefits of these subsidy programs faces an inner difficulty in considering that the sought-after results are not strictly optimal economically. There is a risk that countries, especially the U.S. and China, will adopt increasingly broad definitions of what constitutes a strategic sector, triggering new ‘global subsidy wars’. For countries with no fiscal space to, if they wish, compete in cutting-edge strategic sectors this is bad news.

 

RELATED CONTENT

  • Authors
    May 16, 2024
    L'intégration de l'Intelligence Artificielle (IA) en Afrique laisse entrevoir des perspectives prometteuses et pose des défis substantiels. Si certains pays du continent se distinguent par leur engagement et leurs avancées dans la préparation à l'adoption de l'IA, d'autres font face à des obstacles majeurs, tels que les inégalités structurelles et les fractures numériques. Cette disparité souligne la nécessité d'une approche inclusive et holistique pour garantir que tous ...
  • May 15, 2024
    En 2023, et selon le think tank américain « Atlantic Council », 114 pays ont engagé une réflexion sur La Monnaie numérique de banque centrale (MNBC). Cette réflexion concerne la MNBC de gros, visant à repenser l’interbancarité et la MNBC de détail, celle que la Chine développe avec un succès certain depuis 2014 avec son e yuan, réservé aujourd’hui au seul marché intérieur chinois, en attendant mieux. L’objet de ce Policy Brief est, tout d’abord, de rappeler que les MNB ...
  • Authors
    Bruce Byiers
    Saloi El Yamani
    May 14, 2024
    As the African Continental Free Trade Area (AfCFTA) enters its fifth year, the rules of origin for trade in goods are still being finalised, but the institutional architecture is nearly complete with increased capacity, technical committees and new supporting instruments. Despite this progress in AfCFTA ‘policy supply’, meaningful trade under the AfCFTA is still to begin. For this to happen, there must be ‘policy demand’ from the private sector to use the agreement’s range of protoc ...
  • Authors
    Abdelkhalek Touhami
    Dorothee Boccanfuso
    May 9, 2024
    L'idée d'un effritement de la classe moyenne marocaine est répandue, suggérant un glissement vers une classe aisée toujours plus riche et des classes plus pauvres ce qui sous-entend une augmentation de la polarisation dans la société. Cependant, aucune étude basée sur des données n'a été menée pour confirmer cette perception. Notre étude comble ce vide en analysant l'évolution de la classe moyenne entre 2012 et 2019. En utilisant la définition opérationnelle de Abdelkhalek (2014) de ...
  • Authors
    May 6, 2024
    The issue of environmental degradation represents a significant global challenge. It manifests in various forms, including physical alterations such as air pollution, ozone depletion, climate change, marine pollution and biodiversity loss. These changes are proven to be linked to human activities, such as energy production and consumption, tourism and agriculture. Additionally, factors like population growth and health and safety concerns contribute to environmental decline. Is Gro ...
  • May 2, 2024
    This article was originally published on tandfonline.com   This article explores the intricate relationship between economic growth and unemployment across multiple African countries, with a focus on estimating the Okun’s coefficient. Data from the International Labour Office (ILO) and the World Bank’s databases for 39 African nations were utilised. Two distinct methodological approaches, first differences and the Hodrick-Prescott (HP) filter, were employed to assess result robust ...
  • April 30, 2024
    This paper aims to quantify the economic loss from the earthquake that hit Morocco on September 8, 2023, and to evaluate the impact of the five-year reconstruction plan, that will account for roughly 8.5% of GDP. Given the geographically concentrated location of the earthquake, which hit some provinces in the central part of Morocco, the methodology used relies on an inter- province inter-industry Input-Output (IIO) table for Morocco. Assuming that the resources to be spent on infra ...
  • Authors
    April 29, 2024
    L’Agence française de développement (AFD) et le Policy Center for the New South (PCNS) ont réuni le  17 avril dans les locaux du PCNS, au campus de l’Université Mohammed VI Polytechnique (UM6P) de Rabat, les acteurs du partenariat public-privé dans le secteur de la formation professionnelle. Cet évènement a permis de mettre en lumière le modèle marocain de partenariat public-privé en la matière, notamment les Instituts de formation à gestion déléguée (IGD). Cet évènement s’est ten ...
  • Authors
    April 25, 2024
    The Policy Center for the New South and the Atlantic Council Africa Center have jointly released a report on “The Reform of the Global Financial Architecture: Toward a System that Delivers for the South,” by Otaviano Canuto, Hafez Ghanem, Youssef El Jai, and Stéphane Le Bouder. This report issues specific and urgent calls for reform, including more representative global governance, increasing the World Bank’s operational and financial capacity, prioritizing programs that would inte ...