Publications /
Opinion

Back
The Illusion of Reciprocity in Global Trade – and the Case for a Multipolar Order
August 22, 2025

History offers ample instances in which the veneer of fairness in international relations has worn away, revealing with unsentimental clarity the crude mechanics of power. The contemporary global trade architecture, promoted for decades by the United States as a virtuous system of open markets, a rules-based order, and reciprocal gains, is merely the latest in a long lineage of such illusions.

Like every hegemony before it, the United States now finds itself in a phase of relative decline, no longer honoring the principles it once espoused. Instead, it reaches instinctively for the very instruments it once condemned. The American economic model increasingly relies not merely on domestic productivity and innovation, but on the extraction of value from beyond its borders a twenty-first century economic imperialism artfully draped in the language of “national interest.”

This inversion is as striking as it is consequential: the United States does not primarily generate wealth to sustain the living standards of its citizens; it absorbs it. The centrality of the dollar, the persistent allure of the American market, and perhaps most decisively the unwillingness or inability of other nations to challenge the asymmetries embedded in the global system allow Washington to capture a disproportionate share of the world’s resources. In contrast, others bear the costs of maintaining this imbalance.

The result is a systemic transfer of wealth masquerading as free trade. Developing and middle-income nations are steadily drained of their productive value to underwrite American consumption and geopolitical dominance. Under this dispensation, trade is no longer a vehicle for mutual prosperity but an instrument of extraction and control.

Recent data from Debt Justice UK shatters another common misconception namely, that China is the primary cause of debt distress in the Global South. Between 2020 and 2025, external debt payments of lower-income countries to private lenders were three times higher than those to Chinese public and private creditors. Bondholders, commercial banks, and commodity traders have claimed a significantly larger share of these nations’ scarce revenues revenues that could otherwise be used to fund education, infrastructure, or climate resilience. Multilateral repayments are also surging, a consequence of pandemic-era lending now maturing under a far less forgiving interest-rate environment. Ethiopia, Ghana, Zambia, and Malawi are not struggling primarily because of Beijing; their difficulties stem from a web of creditors whose terms reflect the unflinching logic of profit maximization.

What emerges from these trends is the persistence of the old core-periphery structure, merely dressed in the attire of twenty-first-century finance. Despite its liberal democratic rhetoric, Washington operates according to the logic of zero-sum gain: dominate or be dominated. Reducing domestic consumption, rebalancing fiscal accounts, or boosting productivity is deemed politically untenable. Far easier to shift the burden outward to press partners, punish rivals, and coerce allies all under the banner of “fairness.” One might be forgiven for suspecting that in Washington’s lexicon, “fairness” means whatever benefits Washington.

This is why dismissing alternatives such as BRICS+ is not caution; it is capitulation. The tired critique that BRICS+ merely swaps dependency on Washington for dependency on Beijing willfully ignores that the grouping lacks the coercive conditionality of the IMF or World Bank. In a genuinely multipolar environment, competing sources of capital increase a nation’s bargaining power. Dependency, where it exists, can be negotiated, balanced, and, when necessary, strategically reduced offering reassurance of fair trade practices in the future.

Equally misguided is the argument that the internal heterogeneity of BRICS undermines its value. ASEAN’s flexible architecture did not prevent it from becoming a formidable force in Asia’s diplomatic and commercial landscape. BRICS+ is not NATO; it is a platform, not a bloc designed to accommodate diverse systems and perspectives, to convene without imposing rigid alignment, and to enhance global trade and multilateralism.

For Latin America and much of the Global South, the key strategic question is not whether to align with Washington or Beijing, nor whether to pledge loyalty to the Bretton Woods system or BRICS+. It is whether to embrace the structural logic of multipolarity a system in which power is distributed among multiple poles or centers, rather than concentrated in a single entity. This approach allows nations to hedge, diversify, and translate systemic shifts into tangible national advantage. 

The future global economy cannot rest upon the perpetuation of privilege but must instead be grounded in symmetry. This demands clarity: access to the U.S. market is not a benevolent concession; it is a transaction, subject to leverage, renegotiation, and, where circumstances require, strategic decoupling. It calls for renewed investment in industrial capacity, diversified trade relationships, the restoration of sovereign development agendas, and the recognition that genuine sovereignty is incompatible with structural dependency.

The United States is entitled to pursue its interests; others are equally entitled indeed, obliged to pursue theirs. Only then can the world begin to construct an international economic order in which rules are negotiated, not dictated, and growth is shared, not extracted.

 

RELATED CONTENT

  • February 28, 2022
    La guerre russo-ukrainienne aura des répercussions économiques et politiques dans les années à venir. Dans cette note, nous nous intéressons aux implications économiques de la guerre sur l’économie africaine à court et à long terme. Le conflit survient alors que l’Afrique s’efforce de mettre son économie sur la voie de la reprise, dans un contexte de pressions inflationnistes mondiales et de volatilité des marchés financiers et des matières premières. Alors que les exportateurs d’én ...
  • February 28, 2022
    The Russian-Ukrainian war will have major economic and political repercussions. In this note, we focus on the war’s economic short and long term implications on the African economy. This conflict comes at very arduous context, where Africa is still struggling to set its economy on the recovery path, amid global inflationary pressures and highly uncertain context. While natural resources countries, especially energy exporters, are sensing opportunities from the crisis, other countrie ...
  • Authors
    Patricia Ahanda
    February 23, 2022
    Le Sommet Union européenne (UE) - Union africaine (UA), qui s’est tenu à Bruxelles les 17 et 18 février 2022, entend marquer un tournant dans les relations entre les deux continents. L’agenda européen pour l’année 2022 met au centre de ses priorités les relations Europe - Afrique. Celles-ci sont aussi l'un des principaux axes défendus par la Présidence française du Conseil de l’Union européenne (PFUE) et le Président français Emmanuel Macron dans de son discours inaugur ...
  • Authors
    Nassim Hajouji
    February 15, 2022
    Using education and elite configurations as the main variables of analysis, this Policy Paper aims to show how higher levels of popular sector incorporation during elite conflicts, namely in the process of formulating and implementing policies related to education reforms, can negatively affect the economic complexity of developing countries. To do so, it analyzes the experiences of Mauritius and Singapore and links foundational political economy theories, particularly developmental ...
  • Authors
    January 26, 2022
    The year began with simultaneous signs of a slowdown in global economic growth and a reorientation toward tightening of monetary policies in advanced economies. In its latest Global Economic Prospects released on January 11, the World Bank forecasts that, after a global growth surprisingly at 5.5% last year, it should moderate to somewhere around 4.1% and 3.2%. % in, respectively, 2022 and 2023. In addition to the effects of omicron at the start of the year, less fiscal support and ...
  • Authors
    January 12, 2022
    Feeble eyesight may hinder you from finding Puntland on a map, the unrecognized Federal member state in Somalia, Khaatumo State, Jubaland, or Somaliland, concerning the planet’s size just large enough to be covered by the shadow of a palm tree. Arab entities surrounded by sun and sand and the Gulf of Aden, Somaliland is surviving as a self-declared nation, located on the southern coast of the Gulf of Aden bordered by Djibouti to the northwest, Ethiopia to the south and west, Somalia ...
  • Authors
    December 29, 2021
    Après une longue période de prix atones, le café a vu ses cours se raffermir au cours de l’année 2020 et du premier trimestre 2021, avant de flamber durant l’été et l’automne. Il renouait alors avec des plus hauts niveaux depuis 2011, date de la fin du dernier « super-cycle des matières premières (2002-2011). Tandis que la demande progresse structurellement, l’offre s’est repliée, pénalisée par une conjonction de facteurs climatiques, géopolitiques et, bien évidemment, sanitaires en ...
  • Authors
    December 16, 2021
    We provide evidence on the direct and indirect effects of trade and infrastructure on women’s participation in the labor force. We use panel data from 91 developing and emerging economies, and examine the impacts of openness to international trade and three indicators of infrastructure (access to electricity, mobile phone subscriptions and internet use) on female labor force participation. Fixed-effects and instrumental variable fixed-effects estimates suggest that both trade and ac ...
  • December 13, 2021
    The African Continental free Trade Area (AfCfTA) finally entered into force on the first month of 2021, after the 22nd country ratified the agreement. It is a one of the flagship projects of the African Union 2063 agenda, but It is a first step on a long journey to African Economic inte...