Publications /
Policy Paper

Back
The International Justice System: The ICJ, the ICC, the Challenge and Risk of Double Standards
Authors
April 25, 2025

The International Court of Justice and the International Criminal Court play key roles in upholding international law but face criticism over selective enforcement. The ICJ’s reliance on state consent and UN Security Council enforcement often weakens its impact, while the ICC’s jurisdictional limits and selective prosecutions raise concerns about equity. Contrasting global responses to similar rulings reveal geopolitical influences. The study underscores the need for institutional reform to strengthen credibility, ensure consistent application of international law, and restore trust, particularly in the Global South.

RELATED CONTENT

  • Authors
    February 27, 2019
    This policy brief outlines the debate surrounding the ICC’s focus on (sub-Saharan) Africa, describing how the Court has become the de facto court of transitional justice in Africa, and arguing that a realist theoretical framework can best explain its performance. The author follows a balance of power approach and a post-colonial perspective that help elucidate the ICC’s decisions as well as the maneuverings within the African Union around the tribunal. ...
  • Authors
    March 15, 2018
    « Revise, Reboot, Rebuild : Strategies for a time of Distrust »: that was this year’s theme for the Brussels Forum, a yearly high-level conference held from March 8th to 10th by the US think tank German Marshall Fund (GMF), partner of the OCP Policy Center who attended the event through its delegation. This meeting of some 400 policymakers, academics and private sector operators is reviewing the relationship between Europe and the United States. Brexit, the Trump administration ...