Publications /
Policy Paper

Back
On Additional Issues in the Western Sahara Advisory Opinion
Authors
January 21, 2021

In the Western Sahara Advisory Opinion, formal questions specifically requested by the General Assembly were only on terra nullius and ‘legal ties’ at the time of Spain’s colonization of the Saharan Provinces. however, two other issues, which had not been specifically requested, were added to the formal question of ‘legal ties.” The additional issues concern the right to self- determination and ‘territorial sovereignty.’ The statements on additional issues have recently been referred to in the courts. Was the issue of the right to self-determination indispensable in deciding on ‘legal ties’ in 1884? The statements throughout the Western Sahara Advisory Opinion would indicate that the addition was politically motivated, under the guise of assisting the General Assembly in solving the Saharan Issue. Furthermore, in the statements, ‘territorial sovereignty’ is focused practically on ‘legal ties’ in a contradictory manner, because the opinion declares that ‘legal ties’ should not be limited to territorial ties. However, the phrase, “legal ties of allegiance,” which was demonstrated as one of the ‘legal ties,’ was referred to only to confirm the non-existence of a territorial tie between the Saharan Provinces and Morocco or Mauritania. Such statements shall be considered more specifically in relation to Article 65 (2), providing for ‘a written request.’ They may not form precedents. In the end, a proper way international and domestic courts or States should adopt when invoking the statements in advisory opinions, taking the Saharan Advisory Opinion as an example.

RELATED CONTENT

  • Authors
    Khadija Mamouni
    September 30, 2025
    This article analyzes the role played by Türkiye as an emerging “middle power”[1], in Africa over the last two decades. It argues that a certain discontinuity can be identified in Türkiye’s foreign policy approach in Africa. The approach has shifted from short-term involvement with African nations to more focused, constructive, vision-oriented partnerships. In addition, Türkiye’s gradual rapprochement with Africa began with a soft-power approach through a humanitarian, cultural, and ...
  • September 24, 2025
    Il y a presque deux ans, le Burkina Faso, le Mali et le Niger ont quitté la CEDEAO (Communauté économique des États de l’Afrique de l’Ouest) - Organisation régionale regroupant quinze pays- pour créer un nouveau groupement d’intégration: l’Alliance des États du Sahel (AES).  Les motivations des trois pays ne sont pas conjoncturelles. Elles reflètent les difficultés de l’Organisation régionale à accompagner les pays en question dans leur quête de sécurité et de développemen ...
  • Authors
    September 22, 2025
    Le Processus des États de l’Afrique atlantique (PEAA), lancé par Sa Majesté le Roi Mohammed VI en novembre 2023, ambitionne de transformer la façade atlantique africaine — jusqu’ici morcelée et vulnérable — en un espace géopolitique cohérent, intégré et prospère. L’Initiative s’appuie sur les provinces du Sud marocain comme pont stratégique vers les vingt- trois pays riverains de l’Atlantique, et sur une vision d’ouverture Sud-Sud et euro-africaine.Malgré des disparité ...
  • Authors
    Patricia Ahanda
    September 18, 2025
    L’autrice de cette opinion, Patricia Ahanda, est une alumna du programme Atlantic Dialogues Emerging Leaders 2018. Cette opinion a été publiée initialement sur patriciaahanda.paris Dans un monde marqué par l’émergence d’une instabilité géopolitique globale, par la non-linéarité et l’imprévisibilité croissante des rapports de force, le Maroc s’impose comme un leader pivot du Sud global. Un acteur incontournable capable de relier continents, blocs et cultures dans un mo ...
  • Authors
    September 15, 2025
    The October 2025 general elections in Tanzania unfold within a political culture grounded in consensus and institutional continuity. President Samia Suluhu Hassan’s leadership has reopened political space by restoring elite dialogue, easing restrictions on rallies, and facilitating the return of exiled figures. Yet the exclusion of CHADEMA—the principal opposition party—highlights the enduring limits of pluralism. This paper analyzes the Tanzanian electoral process less as a convent ...