Publications /
Policy Paper

Back
In Search of a Plan B: Like-Minded Internationalism and the Future of Global Development
Authors
Stephan Klingebiel
Andy Sumner
May 12, 2025

Though the international order has changed greatly over the past decades, the transformation now underway is significantly deeper and more profound. The post-1945 multilateral system—largely constructed under U.S. hegemony and framed by liberal values including open markets, rules-based cooperation, and a commitment to global development—is fragmenting. Over the past decade, a series of systemic shocks, including the COVID-19 pandemic, rising geopolitical tensions, and the return of great-power competition, has exposed the limitations of traditional multilateralism. The recent withdrawal of the United States from Agenda 2030 and the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), alongside its increasingly transactional foreign policy under the second Trump administration, marks a decisive break from the consensus that has underpinned global governance in recent decades. This development has profound implications for international cooperation, particularly in the fields of development, climate, and global public goods.

In this context, this paper develops the concept of like-minded internationalism—a form of collective action that relies on coalitions of countries and actors aligned around shared normative commitments and pragmatic objectives, rather than formal multilateral structures or hegemonic or hierarchical leadership. Like-minded coalitions, we argue, offer a viable institutional response to a more multipolar, contested, and volatile international system. Rather than seeking universal consensus, they build issue-based alliances that are flexible, pluralistic, and often innovative in form. They have the potential to achieve more than the lowest common denominator typically reached by less like-minded groups. Importantly, they reflect a shift from global governance premised on inclusion and universality, to a logic of selective cooperation driven by convergence on key goals.

The paper is structured as follows. Section 2 gives a historical perspective on the current moment, tracing the rise and partial erosion of liberal multilateralism, and the emergence of new geopolitical fault lines. Section 3 expands on the concept of like-minded internationalism. Section 4 explores two illustrative cases—UNITAID and the High Ambition Coalition—highlighting the conditions under which like-minded coalitions emerge and the political dynamics that sustain them. Drawing on a policy process framework, we analyze how these initiatives were shaped by actors and networks, context and opportunism, and narratives and evidence. The paper concludes by reflecting on the implications of like- minded internationalism for the future of global cooperation, suggesting that it represents not a retreat from multilateralism, but an adaptive response to its breakdown—one rooted in coalitional agency, institutional pluralism, and strategic pragmatism.

RELATED CONTENT

  • Authors
    June 18, 2025
    In 2000, The Economist dismissed Africa as the “Hopeless Continent”—a label reflecting a broader system of marginalization rooted in colonial legacy and post-Cold War neglect. This essay offers a realist reappraisal, arguing that Africa’s growing strategic relevance is not the result of benevolence, but of structural necessity.Amid a fracturing global order and the rise of transactional geopolitics under Trump 2.0’s Bessent Doctrine, Africa has become indispensable: rich in critical ...
  • Authors
    Pepe Zhang
    Fernando Straface
    June 13, 2025
    This Paper was originally published on cebri.org Within an ever-evolving system of multilateral development banks (MDB) currently reshaped by four structural geo-economic trends, the emergence of new MDBs like the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank (AIIB) and the New Development Bank (NDB) carries great geopolitical significance. Yet the new MDBs, attuned to institutional and operational realities, have not upended the MDB system. Their relationship with long-e ...
  • June 10, 2025
    في هذه الحلقة من برنامج "حديث الثلاثاء"، نناقش المبادرة الملكية المغربية لربط دول الساحل بالمحيط الأطلسي، ودور موريتانيا كشريك استراتيجي في تنفيذها. يسلط الضيف خالد الشكراوي الضوء على أهمية الموقع الجغرافي لموريتانيا وتحولها السياسي كمقومات رئيسية للمساهمة في هذا المشروع. تشكل المبادرة ...
  • Authors
    Alberto Tagliapietra
    Guilherme Casarões
    May 14, 2025
    Global governance is undergoing a profound transformation, marked by growing polarization, the weakening of multilateral institutions, and the rise of informal, flexible frameworks. As great powers drift from multilateral commitments, and instead prioritize transactional or unilateral actions, middle powers are emerging as key actors in shaping the future of global governance. These countries, ranging from Brazil and South Africa to Poland, Türkiye, and South Korea, navigate the in ...
  • Authors
    Stephan Klingebiel
    Andy Sumner
    May 12, 2025
    Though the international order has changed greatly over the past decades, the transformation now underway is significantly deeper and more profound. The post-1945 multilateral system—largely constructed under U.S. hegemony and framed by liberal values including open markets, rules-based cooperation, and a commitment to global development—is fragmenting. Over the past decade, a series of systemic shocks, including the COVID-19 pandemic, rising geopolitical tensions, and the return of ...
  • Authors
    Danielle Alakija
    May 1, 2025
    The author of this opinion, Danielle Alakija, is a 2024 alumna of the Atlantic Dialogues Emerging Leaders Program. Once upon a time—or so the story went—the Global South was cast to the margins of the global development narrative. Assigned a supporting role in someone else’s story, it was exploited for its resources and subdued by the authoritative tone of external narrators. This image, painted in tones of crisis and dependency, continues to echo through textbooks and news cy ...
  • Authors
    Isabela Carvalho
    April 30, 2025
    The author of this opinion, Isabela Carvalho, is a 2018 alumna of the Atlantic Dialogues Emerging Leaders Program. In today’s interconnected world, knowledge plays a vital role in driving change and shaping solutions. Yet despite the rise of digital tools and global collaboration, persistent gaps in how knowledge is managed and shared continue to limit the Global South’s ability to fully harness its potential. Strengthening resilient knowledge ecosystems fosters inclusive ...