Publications /
Policy Paper

Back
In Search of a Plan B: Like-Minded Internationalism and the Future of Global Development
Authors
Stephan Klingebiel
Andy Sumner
May 12, 2025

Though the international order has changed greatly over the past decades, the transformation now underway is significantly deeper and more profound. The post-1945 multilateral system—largely constructed under U.S. hegemony and framed by liberal values including open markets, rules-based cooperation, and a commitment to global development—is fragmenting. Over the past decade, a series of systemic shocks, including the COVID-19 pandemic, rising geopolitical tensions, and the return of great-power competition, has exposed the limitations of traditional multilateralism. The recent withdrawal of the United States from Agenda 2030 and the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), alongside its increasingly transactional foreign policy under the second Trump administration, marks a decisive break from the consensus that has underpinned global governance in recent decades. This development has profound implications for international cooperation, particularly in the fields of development, climate, and global public goods.

In this context, this paper develops the concept of like-minded internationalism—a form of collective action that relies on coalitions of countries and actors aligned around shared normative commitments and pragmatic objectives, rather than formal multilateral structures or hegemonic or hierarchical leadership. Like-minded coalitions, we argue, offer a viable institutional response to a more multipolar, contested, and volatile international system. Rather than seeking universal consensus, they build issue-based alliances that are flexible, pluralistic, and often innovative in form. They have the potential to achieve more than the lowest common denominator typically reached by less like-minded groups. Importantly, they reflect a shift from global governance premised on inclusion and universality, to a logic of selective cooperation driven by convergence on key goals.

The paper is structured as follows. Section 2 gives a historical perspective on the current moment, tracing the rise and partial erosion of liberal multilateralism, and the emergence of new geopolitical fault lines. Section 3 expands on the concept of like-minded internationalism. Section 4 explores two illustrative cases—UNITAID and the High Ambition Coalition—highlighting the conditions under which like-minded coalitions emerge and the political dynamics that sustain them. Drawing on a policy process framework, we analyze how these initiatives were shaped by actors and networks, context and opportunism, and narratives and evidence. The paper concludes by reflecting on the implications of like- minded internationalism for the future of global cooperation, suggesting that it represents not a retreat from multilateralism, but an adaptive response to its breakdown—one rooted in coalitional agency, institutional pluralism, and strategic pragmatism.

RELATED CONTENT

  • October 24, 2025
    Georg Charpentier, Senior Advisor at CMI Martti Ahtisaari Centershares insights on the dynamics of United Nations peace operations and regional stability. He underscores the importance of ...
  • October 23, 2025
    The UN’s funding crisis, fueled by unpaid contributions and expanding mandates, is worsening as U.S. disengagement strains peacekeeping and development efforts, particularly in Africa. This shift also strengthens rivals like China and Russia and raises deeper questions about the legitim...
  • October 23, 2025
    Depuis plus de trente ans, les relations entre le Maroc et l’Union européenne (UE) se caractérisent par un équilibre entre pragmatisme politique, ouverture économique et convergence stratégique. Le processus de Barcelone de 1995 a marqué le début d’une coopération euro-méditerranéenne renforcée, consolidée par l’Accord du Statut avancé en 2008 et le Partenariat euro-marocain de prospérité partagée, faisant de l’UE le principal partenaire économique du Royaume. Dans un contexte régio ...
  • Authors
    Leonardo Párraga
    October 9, 2025
    The author of this opinion, Leonardo Párraga, is a 2016 alumnus of the Atlantic Dialogues Emerging Leaders Program. The next chapter of peacebuilding won’t be written only around the negotiating table or in United Nations chambers. Traditional peacebuilding processes have been characterized by exclusion of some of the key stakeholders that can make them more sustainable: women, young people, and local communities. This trend has been seen in recent peace agreements. For example ...
  • Authors
    October 1, 2025
    The era of relative stability grounded in post-Second World War idealism, and a global compact around the principle of supporting the most vulnerable, is coming to an abrupt close. In its place is hard-nosed realpolitik, raw power, and transactional politics. The current discordant, fractious epoch—despite the sense of foreboding and crises in some quarters—may yet create the space and conditions for much needed honest dialogue on the future of development cooperation. This dialogue ...
  • Authors
    Khadija Mamouni
    September 30, 2025
    This article analyzes the role played by Türkiye as an emerging “middle power”[1], in Africa over the last two decades. It argues that a certain discontinuity can be identified in Türkiye’s foreign policy approach in Africa. The approach has shifted from short-term involvement with African nations to more focused, constructive, vision-oriented partnerships. In addition, Türkiye’s gradual rapprochement with Africa began with a soft-power approach through a humanitarian, cultural, and ...
  • September 25, 2025
    This episode examines the African Peace and Security Architecture  amid evolving threats, questioning its effectiveness against modern crises such as terrorism, environmental stress, disinformation, and cyber risks. It highlights institutional and political gaps, exploring the chal...
  • September 24, 2025
    The African Atlantic Gas Pipeline will transform energy access across West Africa and link the continent to Europe. Stretching over 5,700 km, it will deliver 30 billion cubic meters of gas per year across Africa and 18 billion to Europe, providing electricity for over 400 million people...
  • September 17, 2025
    Cet épisode s’interroge sur l’avenir des blocs régionaux africains, pris entre l’idéal d’intégration et une réalité marquée par la fragmentation. De la fragilisation de la CEDEAO à l’émergence de l’Alliance des États du Sahel, en passant par l’influence croissante d’acteurs extérieurs, ...
  • August 28, 2025
    Alors que l’ordre mondial bascule vers un système multipolaire, l’Afrique se trouve face à un tournant décisif. Comment éviter la marginalisation et tirer parti de ses atouts stratégiques ? Entre partenariats concurrentiels des grandes puissances, montée du Sud global et élargissement d...