Publications /
Opinion

Back
Anthem Protest
Authors
August 24, 2020

During the medal ceremony at the Olympic Stadium in Mexico City on October 16, 1968, two Black American athletes, Tommie Smith and John Carlos, each raised a gloved fist during the playing of the U.S. national anthem. The two Americans received their medals shoeless, but wearing black socks to represent black poverty. Smith wore a black scarf around his neck to present black pride. Carlos, who won a bronze medal, wore a necklace of beads, which he said “were for those individuals that were lynched or killed and that no-one said a prayer for, that were hung and tarred. It was for those thrown of the side of the boats in the Middle Passage”.

The demonstration by the Black American athletes is regarded as “one of the most overtly political statements in the history of the modern Olympics”.  International Olympic Committee President Avery Brundage, who had been president of the U.S. Olympic Committee in 1936, and willing to tolerate the Nazi salute in Hitler’s Olympic Stadium in Berlin, ordered Smith and Carlos suspended from the U.S. team and banned them from the Olympic Village. Gold medalist Smith expected problems after his gesture and had checked out of the Olympic Village the evening prior to the 200 meters final. Yet “the storm in which we were caught up”, Smith told me in an interview two decades later, was unexpected in its destructive violence, including death threats. “People remember this moment. At least we provoked questions. I did not intend anything else. We were quiet, did not throw any rocks and suffered”. Would he repeat such a gesture? “Probably not. I would deal with it differently, more intellectual, in a more psychological way. I would write and speak”. When we met at California’s modest Santa Monica College, Smith was a coach and professor of sports, well aware that his students had no idea why their professor had provoked global headlines.

Protesting Organized Brutality

Now, 52 years later (Smith is 76), another athlete is following Smith’s path, an American football player named Colin Kaepernick, 32. Kaepernick began a silent protest against racism and police brutality in 2016, defying the rules of his club, the San Francisco 49ers and the league, which expected its players to stand during the national anthem, their right hand above the heart. Kaepernick, who knelt on one knee during the anthem, said “I am not protesting the anthem or the nation, I am protesting organized brutality”. When he opted out of his contract in 2017, no other club was willing to sign him, particularly since U.S. President Donald Trump threatened Kaepernick and the owners of the National Football League (NFL). At a political rally in Huntsville, Alabama, the U.S. President suggested NFL owners should fire players who kneel during the national anthem. But in the games following Trump’s speech, more than 200 players sat or knelt during the anthem; others linked arms with their team mates or raised fists as Tommie Smith and John Carlos had at the Olympics half a century ago. Kaepernick has still not been signed by a football team, but by Nike instead, turning him into an icon. He has been promoted by Nike as a symbol fit for our time: one man against the establishment.

And suddenly, so it seems, American corporations have discovered, after the brutal killing of George Floyd in May, that racism does exist in America, that 400 years of slavery have not evaporated from hearts and minds and souls, but is rooted in U.S. culture. Online cultural magazine Complex asked: “Why now? Why didn’t Walmart say ‘Black lives matter’ when a police officer killed John Crawford III in an Ohio Walmart in 2014, like it did weeks after Floyd’s death? Why didn’t NASCAR ban Confederate flags on cars after Sandra Bland died in police custody in 2015, like it did weeks after Floyd’s death? Why do Black lives finally matter enough for companies to make changes unprecedented in their history?” According to Complex“There’s a financial incentive for companies to support black people”. Back in 2018, Nike aired a commercial supporting Colin Kaepernick. Angry Americans burned Nike apparel and pledged to boycott the brand. Kapernick hasn’t played in years, but his message has spread. When the National Basketball League restarted their national tournament in Orlando, Florida, in July, most players, coaches, and referees knelt when the national anthem was played.

Nike’s gamble paid off. In the first weeks after Kaepernick was featured in its contested commercial Nike became $6 billion more valuable after its stock price rose. Meanwhile, Google has committed $12 million, while both Facebook and Amazon are donating $10 million, to various groups fighting against racial injustice. Apple is pledging $100 million for a new Racial Equity and Justice Initiative that will “change the systemic barriers to opportunity and dignity that exist for communities of color, and particularly for the black community”, according to Apple CEO Tim Cook. Walmart, the supermarket corporation, will contribute $100 million over five years to create a new center for racial equity. Fast food giant McDonalds is committing $1 million to the U.S. National Association for the Advancement of Colored People and the National Urban League. Other companies have made similar pledges and statements in support of Black communities.

Time will tell whether such pledges are just a PR attempt, or are really driven by the urgency of confronting the abandonment of Black America. The U.S. establishment is white. At the Oscars in 2015 and 2016, only whites were nominated in the acting categories. How many four-star generals are black? Out of 38, there is only one (as of May 2020). Less than 2% of musicians in American orchestras are Black Americans. Former basketball player Michael Jordan knows that only his sporting ability allowed him to escape poverty, just like Tommie Smith, who grew up with eleven brothers and sisters. Jordan and his brand have pledged $100 million dollars over the next ten years to “organizations dedicated to ensuring racial equality, social justice and greater access to education”.

 

The opinions expressed in this article belong to the author.

RELATED CONTENT

  • August 28, 2026
    يستضيف بودكاست مركز سياسات من أجل الجنوب الجديد الباحث البارز حافظ غانم للحديث عن العلاقة الدائرية بين عدم المساواة وضعف الإنتاجية في بلدان الجنوب الجديد، حيث يغذي كل منهما الآخر في نوع م ...
  • August 14, 2026
    In this Episode, Arup Banerji discusses why local expertise—not just international advice—should be intentionally embedded in African development policy. He cites cash transfer programs a ...
  • Authors
    Oussama Zennati
    August 4, 2026
    This paper was originaly published on Middle East Development Journal This article examines the impact of remittances on human capital formation, living conditions, and economic participation of women in North African countries. While prior research has explored remittances’ effects on women’s access to fundamental rights, it has not fully captured the social and economic transformations induced by these funds. Our findings indicate that remittances significantly enhance w ...
  • July 3, 2026
    Depuis plusieurs semaines, l'Afrique du Sud vivait au rythme d'une échéance sans existence légale. Au 30 juin, des mouvements anti-immigration avaient fixé la date à laquelle les étrangers en situation irrégulière devaient, selon eux, avoir quitté le pays. Le gouvernement Sud-africain a même dû démentir qu'il s'agissait d'une directive officielle du ministère de l'Intérieur. L’initiative a pourtant produit des effets importants : des milliers de ressortissants mozambicains, malawite ...
  • June 30, 2026
    À l'échelle mondiale, les politiques publiques de jeunesse sont confrontées à un double enjeu : répondre à des défis socio-économiques structurels; chômage, précarité, fractures territoriales, tout en intégrant une demande croissante de participation citoyenne effective. (OIT, 2023 ; Nations Unies, 2020) En Afrique, ce défi revêt une dimension singulière compte tenu du poids démographique de la jeunesse et des fragilités persistantes des démocraties locales. (BAD, 2020 ; Mo Ibrahim ...
  • June 30, 2026
    Globally, public policies for youth face a twofold challenge: addressing structural socioeconomic challenges—such as unemployment, precariousness, and regional disparities—while accommodating a growing demand for effective civic participation. (ILO, 2023; United Nations, 2020) In Africa, this challenge takes on a unique dimension given the demographic weight of the youth population and the persistent fragility of local democracies. (AfDB, 2020; Mo Ibrahim Foundation, 2023)Elections ...
  • June 26, 2026
    In Morocco, the issue of young NEETs (Not in Employment, Education, or Training) is a national emergency, fueled by 300,000 students dropping out of school each year. In response to this challenge, the “New Generation Second Chance School” (E2C-NG) model has proven its effectiveness by achieving an exceptional employment rate of 81%.However, this institutional success rests entirely on a local network of organizations that is now under strain. A previously unpublished analysis of da ...
  • June 26, 2026
    Au Maroc, la problématique des jeunes NEETs (Ni en emploi, ni en études, ni en formation) constitue une urgence nationale, alimentée par 300 000 abandons scolaires annuels. Face à ce défi, le modèle de l'École de la Deuxième chance nouvelle génération (E2C-NG) a démontré sa pertinence en affichant un taux d'insertion exceptionnel de 81 %.Cependant, ce succès institutionnel repose intégralement sur un tissu associatif local aujourd'hui fragilisé. L'analyse inédite des donné ...
  • June 15, 2026
    Ce papier a été initialement publié dans la revue Carrefours de l'éducation n°61 L’écart entre les sexes en matière de réussite éducative demeure une préoccupation majeure au Maroc. Cette étude analyse les disparités de genre en lecture et en mathématiques aux niveaux national, urbain et rural, en exploitant des données individuelles issues de l’évaluation PIRLS 2021 (7 017 élèves) et de TIMSS 2019 (13 536 élèves), toutes deux menées auprès d’élèves de 4e année du primaire. En ...